Stop Wasting Time Sifting Through Hundreds of Applications: The Secret to Hiring the Perfect Virtual Assistant

Stop Wasting Time Sifting Through Hundreds of Applications: The Secret to Hiring the Perfect Virtual Assistant

June 26, 20242 min read

Discover the hidden pitfalls of hiring a virtual assistant and the simple strategy I used to cut through the noise, find the perfect candidate, and reclaim my sanity.

“The key is not to prioritize what's on your schedule, but to schedule your priorities.” - Stephen Covey

I was convinced that hiring a virtual assistant (VA) was the answer to my entrepreneurial prayers. More time, less stress, the freedom to focus on what I do best – it all sounded too good to be true.

And in many ways, it was. At least initially.

My first foray into the world of VA hiring was a disaster. I posted a job ad and braced myself for the influx of applications. What I got was an avalanche. 300 applications flooded my inbox, each one promising the moon and back.

I was drowning in resumes, cover letters, and generic promises. My dream of saving time had morphed into a nightmare of endless scrolling and head-spinning confusion. Every applicant started to look the same, and my frustration mounted.

The Missing Piece: A Simple Trick to Weed Out the Unqualified

I was ready to give up. Then, I stumbled upon a simple yet brilliant strategy that changed everything. I added a few specific questions at the end of my job ad, instructing applicants to answer them in their application.

This one little tweak had a dramatic impact:

  • Instant Filter: Applicants who couldn't be bothered to follow instructions were immediately eliminated.

  • Serious Candidates Only: The remaining applicants had clearly taken the time to read and understand the position, signaling their genuine interest and attention to detail.

  • My pool of 300 applications dwindled to a manageable 20, and the quality of candidates skyrocketed. I was no longer sifting through generic resumes; I was engaging with individuals who had demonstrated their commitment and qualifications.

Beyond the Trick: Essential Lessons for Hiring the Perfect VA

This experience taught me invaluable lessons about hiring virtual assistants:

  • Clarity is King: Your job ad should be crystal clear about the specific skills, experience, and personality traits you're looking for.

  • Don't Be Afraid to Be Selective: It's better to have a smaller pool of highly qualified candidates than a massive pile of generic applications.

  • Test for Attention to Detail: Little things matter! Include specific instructions in your job ad to gauge an applicant's ability to follow directions.

From Overwhelmed to Empowered: The Right VA Can Transform Your Business

Hiring my first VA wasn't a walk in the park, but by implementing this simple trick and refining my hiring process, I found the perfect match.

Don't let your first VA hire be a nightmare. Embrace clarity, be selective, and don't be afraid to test for the qualities that truly matter. The right VA can revolutionize your business, freeing you to focus on what you do best.

What are your biggest challenges when hiring virtual assistants? Share your experiences and tips in the comments below!

Back to Blog

Virtual Assistant

Get a job, build a career - with us! ❤️ We're excited to have you come in for an interview. We think you would be a great fit, and we're confident that you'll enjoy the opportunity.

Business Owners

Want to know everything about how to work with Virtual Assistants and how we close the gap? Schedule a Meeting Now!

Phyllis Song © 2025 | All Rights Reserved